US Supreme Court to Consider Military Malpractice Lawsuit

posted August 3, 2011 | by

According to the Fresno Bee, The U.S. Supreme Court will consider the death of Dean Patrick Witt and its connection to the legal doctrine that shield military personnel from lawsuits, on June 23, 2011. Mr. Witt’s widow, Alexis, has filed a military malpractice case after Witt died from having a breathing tube placed in his esophagus instead of his trachea in October 2003.

Mr. Witt is a native of Sacramento Valley and married Alexis in September 2001, the article said. It continued with the retelling of how Witt died: in October 2003, he was at Travis Air Force Base, preparing to move his wife and two children from Utah. He was diagnosed with acute appendicitis at David Grant Medical Center and had a successful operation. After the surgery he began having difficulty breathing and a nurse, first, mistakenly tried to open his airways with pediatric equipment and, second, placed the (correct) breathing tube in his esophagus instead of in his trachea. The incorrect placement of the breathing tube starved Mr. Witt’s brain of oxygen, leaving him in a vegetative state. He was taken off of life-support on January 9, 2004.

Also according to the article, the supervising nurse surrendered her license after the incident. Mrs. Witt did receive insurance benefits and is receiving a monthly tax-free stipend for her and her children from the military.

While if Mr. Witt had been a civilian, his family would have had an open and shut medical malpractice and wrongful death lawsuit, however, in the 1950s the Supreme Court ruled that military personnel could not sue for injuries occurring “incident to service.” While Congress could change these rules, it would be quite expensive.

It is estimated that medical malpractice lawsuits by military personnel could add 750 lawsuits annually and cost the government $2.7 billion over 10 years, according to the Congressional Budget Office and as cited by the Fresno Bee article.

It is interesting to weigh the options of would it be worth it to allow active-duty military medical malpractice suits with keeping the current standard. What do you think?

Ron Kramer is a Utah personal injury and accident lawyer practicing throughout the state. Call the Kramer Law Group today at 801-601-1229 for a free consultation.

Million Dollar Advocates Forum

“We had a positive experience working with your office. WE appreciate Jeff, keeping us current on our case and returning our calls. He has calm personality and very knowledgeable. He communicated well with us. I also, appreciate Mariana’s customer service. She does an excellent job in making you fell welcomed. She, too has excellent people skills!”

Associations & Memberships

We’re Social! Connect with Us.

Call Us for a Free Consultation


Four Locations to Meet You

We serve clients throughout the entire State of Utah.

West Jordan (Main Office)

8783 S. Redwood Rd. Suite C
West Jordan, UT 84088
Phone: 801-601-1229

Orem (Virtual)

887 W. Center St.
Orem, Utah 84057
Phone: 801-374-7445

Meetings Only

Bountiful (Virtual)

503 West 2600 South Suite 200
Bountiful, Utah 84010
Phone: 801-553-8840

Meetings Only

Ogden (Virtual)

3500 Harrison Blvd.
Ogden, Utah 84403
Phone: 801-553-8840

Meetings Only